Category: Philosophy and Theology

  • Reasoning Together – Zion

    We talk about Zion in a lot of different senses, but I think most of these share the general idea of communally gathering, developing, sharing, and partaking in everything that is lovely, virtuous, or praiseworthy or of good report. How do we do this, both collectively and individually, on both a theological and political level?…

  • Reasoning Together – Prophets

    Reasoning Together – Prophets

    Here’s the main point: I don’t think either our history or our theology supports traditional and currently widespread – though often unarticulated – notions of what a prophet is.[1] 

  • The Approaching Zion Project: How to Get Rich

    The Approaching Zion Project: How to Get Rich

    So here we are, a day early (or, um, six days late, if that’s the way you want to look at it). Since we’re here, let’s take a look at Nibley’s next approach toward Zion:

  • The Approaching Zion Project: Deny Not the Gifts of God

    The Approaching Zion Project: Deny Not the Gifts of God

    This chapter (understandably) overlaps significantly with the previous chapter, Gifts. These are, after all, discourses he delivered at various times, to various audiences, with common themes. I’m reading them separately, though, and different things hit me at different readings. So, like always, I won’t discuss everything Nibley focuses on (and I’ll try to not spend…

  • The Approaching Zion Project: Gifts

    The Approaching Zion Project: Gifts

    For the third (and, I hope, final) time, I read this chapter on an airplane, taking notes as I read it. And there are just a couple quick things I want to highlight and discuss, and one sentence that really troubled me.

  • The Approaching Zion Project: Zeal Without Knowledge

    The Approaching Zion Project: Zeal Without Knowledge

    For the second time, I read this chapter in an airport and on an airplane returning home. With that as my full preface, let’s jump into this chapter:

  • The Approaching Zion Project: What is Zion? A Distant View

    The Approaching Zion Project: What is Zion? A Distant View

    Another confession: I had a really hard time with this chapter. And it’s not just because I read it sitting in an airport waiting for a plane that was delayed for an hour and a half. Rather, it’s because of the way Nibley speaks of the wealthy. Certain of his descriptions feel, to me, so…

  • Stewards of Prudence and Altruism

    Stewards of Prudence and Altruism

    Prudence and altruism combined allow us to delay personal gratification or even make sacrifices for the benefit of future people who have not yet been born. The hearts of the fathers must turn to their children

  • The Approaching Zion Project: Our Glory or Our Condemnation

    The Approaching Zion Project: Our Glory or Our Condemnation

    Now that I’ve read my first chapter of Approaching Zion, a couple more caveats before we get started. First, I’m not going to bother summarizing what Nibley said. Instead, I’m going to try to engage it, responding to ideas that engaged me, whether I agree or disagree. Second, I’m not going to try to engage…

  • How a concussion made me think of Stephenie Meyer and Francis Hutcheson

    How a concussion made me think of Stephenie Meyer and Francis Hutcheson

    Last semester, my first semester studying Greek, I sustained a mild concussion. I have mostly recovered now. I still have problems with bright lights that makes nighttime driving intolerable, but for the most part, I’m functioning normally. But for a few weeks there, I couldn’t think straight. It hurt to concentrate. Reading even a light…

  • Finding My Heavenly Mother, Part 4 (Literary Edition)

    Also see part 1, part 2 and part 3. In a 1944 essay (“Is Theology Poetry?”), C.S. Lewis remarked, “I believe in Christianity as I believe that the sun has risen: not only because I see it, but because by it I see everything else.” As one who embraced Christianity later in life, Lewis had…

  • The God Who Weeps: Faith

    I agree with The God Who Weeps that faith is a decision, but I disagree about the site of this decision.

  • Finding My Heavenly Mother, Part 2

    Finding My Heavenly Mother, Part 2

     The same drive which called art into being as a completion and consummation of existence, and as a guarantee of further existence, gave rise also to that Olympian realm which acted as a transfiguring mirror to the Hellenic “will.” The gods justified human life by living it themselves—the only satisfactory theodicy ever invented.    –…

  • Post-structuralist Mormon?

    I played with deconstruction a little bit this semester. It probably wasn’t a good idea; I didn’t feel I had a firm grasp on Derrida; his ideas squirmed away from me like slippery little fish. But it seemed like so much fun, like such a powerful tool; how could I resist? It was like fire…

  • Exploring Mormon Thought: Sex

    Exploring Mormon Thought: Sex

    I don’t know much about God (which is probably pretty obvious), but I have thought a lot about sex.

  • Exploring Mormon Thought: The Homogeneous?

    Exploring Mormon Thought: The Homogeneous?

    In chapter 8 of The Attributes of God, Ostler continues grappling with the question of human agency in relation to God’s foreknowledge. The professional literature generated by this kind of theological question is wide and deep and the field is no particular speciality of mine. On these kinds of questions, Ostler is much better read…

  • The Scholar of Moab: Interviduality

    The Scholar of Moab: Interviduality

    How many am I?

  • Phantom Limb

    I can’t speak to your experience. I can’t speak even to my own. But I’ll tell a story. I remember the day and time and place that I stopped believing in God, but not the date.

  • Ecce Theologus

    Joseph Spencer is indispensable. He is the “not-thoughtless” and the “never-glosses-over.”

  • Circuitous Machinations – On Mormon Theology

    Circuitous Machinations – On Mormon Theology

    A comically involved, complicated invention, laboriously contrived to perform a simple operation. —“Rube Goldberg,” Webster’s New World Dictionary

  • Desert and a Just Society

    The 2010 poverty level in the U.S., we learned on Tuesday, is the highest it has been since 1993. In 2010, about one in six Americans lived below the poverty line.[fn1] In June, 14.6% of Americans received food stamps.[fn2] To some extent, the high poverty rate is probably related to the high unemployment rate, which…

  • Mormonism and Social Justice

    Recently, we’ve seen some distrust of religions that advocate social justice, from sources as diverse as the political punditry and lay Mormons.[fn1] The criticism is unfounded, of course, and strikes me as ahistorical and anti-Catholic. The term “social justice” comes from 1840, when the Jesuit scholar Luigi Taparelli as he worked through the philosophy of Thomas Aquinas.…

  • Binoculars

    You’re given a pair of binoculars.

  • Grant Hardy’s Subject Problem

    Criticisms of the Book of Mormon generally fall into one of two categories: objections to its historical claims on the one hand, and on the other critiques of its literary style. The two prongs are often combined in a single attack, for instance in the suggestion that the awkward style of the book reflects the…

  • Faith, Philosophy, Scripture: Breathing

    One last post about Jim Faulconer’s Faith, Philosophy, Scripture (Maxwell Institute, 2010). The final chapter is entitled “Breathing” and is a meditation on Romans 8.

  • Faith, Philosophy, Scripture: Reading Zion

    Zion is the world ajar. Zion is the world set on a double hinge. God gives a push, the door goes swinging, and the world opens wide.

  • Rivers of Living Water

    Rivers of Living Water

    It’s Easter and I, like Mary, have a hard time seeing what’s right in front of me.

  • Faith, Philosophy, Scripture: True Believer

    Faith, Philosophy, Scripture: True Believer

    It’s unlikely that I believe the right things about God, Jesus, the gospel, or the Church. It’s even less likely that I could express my beliefs in a coherent and justifiable way. I used to think that, because my ideas were clever, I was at least closer to being right than most. This I took as…

  • Faith, Philosophy, Scripture: Secular Mormons

    Faith, Philosophy, Scripture: Secular Mormons

    The irony of religious fundamentalism is that it is a profoundly modern and profoundly secular phenomenon. This is perhaps especially true of the scriptural literalism that often accompanies it. The result is that many of the most conservative Mormons are, in point of fact, also the most secular. Few Mormons are more secular than Joseph…

  • Peace

    Peace

    Sometimes unintentional mistakes lead to interesting lines of thought. A few weeks ago I misheard a speaker in an LDS meeting. The speaker was quoting John 14:27, and either because of the speaker’s mispronunciation or my imperfect hearing, I heard the word “live” instead of the word “leave.” This lead me to think about what…