A Look at How Religion Is Resilient and Thrives under Disorder and Duress

•

By Kendall Buchanan

Months ago, on the popular blog for “rationalists,” Astral Star Codex, an anonymous poster reviewed, of all things, the Book of Abraham (BoA) , annoying the blog’s small number of Latter-day Saint readers who imagined an outsider could conclude anything but what he did—that BoA is a failed Egyptian translation.

I reviewed the review and argued we Latter-day Saints can’t recognize a compliment when it’s offered. In any case, the poster marveled at an aspect of Mormonism I’ve been itching to write about for years: its bias for resilience and survival when things go wrong.

Most new religious movements die in infancy. How then did Mormonism break from conventional theologies of its time and escape the untimely death met by other radical movements? How did the church Joseph Smith founded absorb his madcap ambitions, many of which exacted heavy tolls on his followers and didn’t pan out in his lifetime?

Here and in three subsequent posts we’ll talk about what makes religion robust—what gives it staying power—drawing first on principles outlined by Nassim Nicholas Taleb, Lebanese probabilist and philosopher (part 1); and second, I’ll propose three traits in Mormonism I think go a long way to explain its stubbornness in the face of failure:

1) its flexible approach to prophecy and revelation (part 2),

2) an abundance of spiritual gifts (part 3), and

3) offering a “thick” religion (part 4).

Christianity, too, was a radical movement that should have died in infancy; and like the early Christians, Mormons faced confounding failure from the start.

Today, some Latter-day Saints seem eager to be accepted into the club of conventional Christianity, despite our unconventional Christian beliefs, and strain to convince themselves of our own normalcy in the secular world.

Cultural accommodation, however, was not how our spiritual forefathers weathered mobs, armies, and extermination threats—Mormonism survived by practicing a distinct kind of doctrinal flexibility buttressed by stubborn goals. Understanding these dynamics, I think, helps us better appreciate threats our faith faces today.

Wine Glasses and Spoons

Taleb, author of The Incerto , studies dynamic systems like people, nations, and institutions, and how they thrive over time. According to Taleb, these systems belong to one of three categories: fragile (disorder breaks them), robust (resilient to disorder), or “anti-fragile” (they gain from disorder). He offers this unusual metaphor: imagine shipping wine glasses across the ocean—poor preparation will break the glasses;

robust packaging will preserve them as expected; but an anti-fragile shipment will create miraculous conditions under which the glasses arrive gold leafed!

Old religions are robust. Taleb helps us see why with a principle he popularized called the “Lindy effect,” which posits that:

the future life expectancy of some non-perishable thing, like a technology or an idea, is proportional to its current age.

He cites the dinner table: spoons, knives, plates, bowls—every tool you eat with has existed for thousands of years; expect them to last thousands more. That call-waiting device you had in the kitchen twenty years ago? Not so much. The upshot is: the longer something has survived, the longer it will yet survive.

Religion is a technology and manifestly “Lindy.” Take Judaism, for example: for much of its history entrance to Judaism happened matrilineally; meaning, to be a proper Jew, your mother had to be Jewish. Interfaith marriage destroyed the link. And unlike modern Christianity—which, in order to overcome churn, relies on evangelizing—Judaism discourages conversion from the outside and keeps a thick membrane between the religion and the Gentile world. Judaism survives in spite of these apparent disadvantages. Its texts, like the Hebrew Bible, have survived for as many as three thousand years. That’s robust!

But what of anti-fragility, this magical ability to gain from disorder?

It takes practice to spot anti-fragility in society, but the natural world offers an example anyone can understand: running, jumping, and lifting weights constitute disorder, yet each stimulates growth in the body. Idleness and sedation, on the other hand, lead to metabolic disease. This is anti-fragility—applied in reasonable doses, over time, anti-fragile systems respond well to exogenous shocks.

Fighting Demons, Evolution, and Sunday School

So from what we’ve learned, a new religious movement is more like an infant in the wilderness: inherently fragile, unlikely to survive, usually folding within a generation. (The rabbi from Smyrna, Sabbatai Zevi , whose claim to be the Messiah swept Judaism, lost credibility within 16 months.) To survive, then, a new religion must exploit nourishment from the competitive landscape even when others want it deprived.

Emile Durkheim—early father of sociology—argued that religion was not about the supernatural, not even specifically about God or the divine:

Religious beliefs are the representations which express the nature of sacred things… the rules of conduct which prescribe how a man should comport himself in the presence of these sacred objects.

In other words, religion defines how we should live, and it’s why religious dynamics arise even in secular contexts.

This dualistic nature of religion—sacred and profane—undergirds a movement’s ability to use opposition like fuel. Just as Evangelical Republicans see Democratic attacks against President Donald Trump as demonic forces marshaling against God’s chosen people, persecution emboldens believers, confirms their sense of purpose, and piques interest in curious observers.

Secondly, religion offers a powerful example of another recurring anti-fragile process: social evolution. Movements that outlast others promote personal sacrifice on behalf of the whole by promising a more rewarding existence on earth and a better life after death. This dynamic turns dull, unpleasant, and even life-threatening (and, unfortunately, sometimes malignant) behaviors into heroic endeavors. It’s the force that motivated early Mormons to live polygamously against every impulse that told them not to. (For what it’s worth, sacrifice, as embodied by religion, I think, is one of life’s deepest truths.)

Thirdly, believers create powerful bonds as they share sacred experiences with each other. Like sacrifice, most group worship is boring (Sunday school), sometimes taxing, and occasionally intense and transcendent (like the “pentecostal” outpourings in Kirtland). Together, participants reenact the expectations of the faith. Consider the one baptized and the one baptizing: the former signals to the latter his intention to live a new life; the latter pledges his help; and witnesses hold them accountable.

These aren’t the only things making religion robust, but combined they give religion the strength to outlast ethnicities, nations, and even languages.

Reaching Intolerant Adolescence

To reach the age of a teenager, having navigated the hazards of infancy and early childhood, our fledgling religious movement might borrow one more principle from Taleb, which he calls “the dictatorship of the small minority” :

The minority rule will show us how all it takes is a small number of intolerant virtuous people with skin in the game, in the form of courage, for society to function properly.

European abolitionism, American prohibitionism, and, according to Taleb, widespread corporate support for kosher products, were each achieved by tyrannically virtuous people.

This “intransigent minority” parallels public choice theory, where a small number of highly motivated actors lobby with, donate to, and even cheat for an issue that impacts them personally. The majority mostly doesn’t share the minority’s passion (indeed, they’re sometimes disgusted by it), but so long as the majority is sufficiently indifferent, and costs are not too high, the intolerant minority will get their way.

In the 21st century, minority rule finds its strongest expression in secular society, as in feminism and gay rights. But, if we’re thinking like Durkheim, secular manifestations of the minority rule are driven by the same religious impulses—that certain things are sacred, and we ought to align our behavior with those things.

Thus a sharp, counter-cultural religious position is like a calling card to potential converts (especially to those disenfranchised by respectable society) and delineates the faithful from an unjust world.

A Gold-Leafed Church

So religion’s robust elements like moderation (fasting), faithfulness (abstinence), and consecration (of holy objects) will continue for many generations, perhaps abated by secular trends and changes in technology, but will survive, because they’re old and battle tested.

But religion as a phenomenon is also anti-fragile! Obviously, some long-lived religious doctrines fall out of favor, as did mass-marketed indulgences and double predestination. When the costs these doctrines impose get out of sync with the benefits, the landscape opens to newcomers with innovations; and because varied religions offer competing answers to what is sacred in life, it is “undeniably possible to arrange [religions] in a hierarchy.”

Which brings us full circle: early Mormonism suffered acute disorder—prejudice, displacement, internal strife, apostasy, extermination threats—and emerged stronger. It was more than resilient to opposition: it benefited from it.

In my next three posts we’ll talk specifically about how Mormonism embarked on the storm-tossed sea, and like Taleb’s wine glasses, arrived with gold leaf on its walls.


Comments

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

This site uses Akismet to reduce spam. Learn how your comment data is processed.