Mark Ellison on How Early Christians Portrayed Jesus

•

Walk down the halls of nearly any Latter-day Saint meetinghouse today, and the artwork feels comfortably familiar: portraits of the Savior featuring shoulder-length auburn hair, a neat beard, and immaculate, flowing white robes. Because this visual tradition has been reinforced by generations of Christian painters—from Renaissance masters to twentieth-century illustrators like Harry Anderson and Del Parson—it is easy to assume that believers have always pictured Jesus this way. Yet ancient material culture tells an entirely different story. In the earliest centuries following Christ’s ministry, Christians depicted him not as an elder monarch, but as a clean-shaven youth, an energetic miracle worker, and a shepherd carrying sheep across Roman catacombs in symbolic, rather than literal, images of Jesus. BYU ancient scripture professor Mark D. Ellison, a co-author of the recent volume Picturing Christ: Understanding Depictions of Jesus in History and Art, explored this visual evolution in an interview at the Latter-day Saint history site From the Desk, explaining how early Christians portrayed Jesus and what those portrayals reveal about ancient faith.

How Did Early Christians Portray Jesus

The Ordinary Galilean

Before examining ancient art, Ellison emphasizes that we must look at what the New Testament says—and does not say—about the historical Jesus. The Gospel authors provide zero physical descriptions of Jesus’s facial features, stature, or hair length. However, they leave unmistakable narrative clues that he blended in seamlessly with the ordinary Galilean working men of his day.

“Judas had to indicate to the arresting party, by a customary kiss of greeting, which of the group was Jesus,” Ellison noted. “This implies that Jesus didn’t significantly stand out from others in his physical appearance. In film and art, we often see Jesus depicted in ways that do make him stand out visually: the disciples wear drab earth tones, but Jesus is clothed in near-white and stands taller than the others, surrounded by light, and so forth. If that had been the historical reality, Judas could have simply said, ‘See the tall one in white who’s glowing? That’s him.’ But he didn’t.”

Furthermore, archaeology, textile remains, and regional burial excavations demonstrate that typical first-century Jewish men in Roman Palestine were relatively short (around 5’4″ to 5’6″), had olive-brown complexions, and wore short, curly dark hair and trimmed beards. Rather than wearing ankle-length robes, day laborers wore knee-length tunics paired with a mantle. In fact, Jesus specifically criticized religious leaders who paraded around in aristocratic, full-length robes to project status. The modern tendency to depict Jesus in long, pristine gowns reflects Victorian orientalism far more than first-century Judean life.

From Pagan Motifs to Imperial Majesty

When Christian art finally began appearing in the archaeological record around 200 CE—primarily within Roman catacombs and domestic worship spaces—it was completely devoid of photographic realism. Instead, early Christians borrowed the visual grammar of the Greco-Roman world to make theological statements.

In scenes painted across early Christian burial chambers, Jesus is often portrayed as a clean-shaven, short-haired Roman youth performing miracles or acting as the Good Shepherd. Rather than creating new symbols from scratch, early converts repurposed familiar pagan motifs to express distinct Christian hope:

“In Greek and Roman art, the god Hermes had long been depicted carrying a sheep on his shoulders,” Ellison explained. “Hermes was regarded as a god who carried departed souls into the afterlife. Christians who adapted the image of the sheep-bearing Hermes could express their belief that it was Christ, not Hermes, who would safely see their souls into the life beyond death.”

As the Church expanded and eventually gained imperial sanction in the fourth century, the artistic depiction transformed once again. Images of Jesus as a youthful Apollo or an itinerant teacher gave way to imperial majesty. Artists began borrowing visual cues from the supreme ruler of the pagan pantheon:

Toward the end of the fourth century, we start to see Jesus depicted quite differently, with long hair and a beard, richly robed and seated magisterially on a throne. This portrait style draws on the traditional depiction of Zeus (or Jupiter) and other senior gods of the pantheon (such as Serapis or Neptune). Over time, this image of the long-haired, bearded Jesus replaced the earlier image of the short-haired, beardless youth, and it became the predominant portrait type in the European artistic tradition.

Conclusion

There is more interesting information in the full conversation with Mark Ellison, including an examination of how ancient Syrian baptisteries depicted New Testament miracles, why second-century critics attacked Jesus’s physical appearance using Isaiah 53, and how shifting theological creeds gradually elevated Christ into an enthroned cosmic ruler. To see the historical frescoes and read the rest of the discussion, check out the full interview on early Christian depictions of Jesus over at From the Desk.

While you’re there, check out the J. Golden Kimball Quotes page!


Comments

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

This site uses Akismet to reduce spam. Learn how your comment data is processed.