Category: Latter-day Saint Thought
-

The Rest of the Story of a Poem
One of the most frequently published and regarded most highly LDS poets of the 19th century was Emily Hill Woodmansee, who is best remembered for the poem “As Sisters in Zion,” currently #309 in the hymnal. For us today, like almost all 19th century poetry, her work might seem rather conventional—it’s almost all written in…
-

Baptisms for the Dead Among the Early Christians: What Does the Literature Say?
Baptisms for the Dead at Corinth Baptisms for the Dead among early Christians is occasionally touched on in apologetics works, but like my earlier piece on female ordination and early Church structure I wanted to do a deeper dive on what the research literature had to say about the subject. I read/perused the articles below…
-

Others in our Meetings (Or What Did Church Lead You to Think About Yesterday), 9/13
Regardless of what we think the ideal Church meeting is like, others are there. While our purpose in going to Church is to worship, we seem to believe that others need to be there. I am not aware of anything that says that we can’t worship by ourselves (and many of our worship practices—prayer, scripture…
-

CFM 9/21-9/27: Thoughts and Poetry for “A Marvellous Work and a Wonder”
“A Marvelous Work and a Wonder” is one of the handful of biblical phrases that our religious tradition has given different meaning from what others understand. Where the phrase in Isaiah is often thought by non-LDS scholars to refer to the confounding of those who think they are wise, the similar language found in the…
-

The Glasses of Twenty Five Years
Today can be painful. It has been painful for me. How it is painful depends on how you see it. Recently I have been taking classes in graduate school. Many of our discussions in class have focused on various ways of looking at the texts we have studied. During most of the past 50 years,…
-

Constructing in our Meetings (Or What Did Church Lead You to Think About Yesterday), 9/6
What are we building in Church, and why? This past week, in one of the Maxwell Institute’s new podcast series “Faith in Every Footnote”, an idea jumped out at me. Observing that in the humanities, students are often given the tools to be critical—to look carefully at a text or an event, and take it…
-

CFM 9/14-9/20: Thoughts and Poetry for “God Is My Salvation”
What is the source of Salvation? We look, of course, to Christ and his atonement for salvation. But when we try to understand how that salvation works, where do we turn? The lesson covers the words of Isaiah, which we are told will all be fulfilled, but Isaiah is sometimes quite obscure to readers today…
-

CFM 9/7-9/13: Thoughts and Poetry for “He Shall Direct Thy Paths”
What is wisdom exactly? Is it the ability to think clearly in a moral context? Is it something that we are learning here on this earth? Is it something that should eventually be independent of our Heavenly Parents? Or is it, by nature, listening to Them? Thinking in this vein, the books of Proverbs and…
-
Everything wrong with the new hymn book (1799 edition, colorized)
From the anonymous Kritik des neuen Dresdnischen Gesangbuchs (“Critique of the new Dresden hymnal”), Strasbourg: Johann von Guttenberg, 1799 (VD18 11538767), pp. 15-20. I also insist that a generally usable song collection should contain all new and good songs that exist. The number that exists cannot be so high as to make such a book…
-
Coduction (learning together) in our Meetings (Or What Did Church Lead You to Think About Yesterday), 8/23
Have you ever had an experience where a conversation with someone else led you to think about things differently, or understand something new? That happens to me a lot. There’s something about talking with others that makes my brain see things differently. This kind of mutual learning, or discovery through conversation is something I’ve found…
-

CFM 8/31-9/6: Thoughts and Poetry for “Let Every Thing That Hath Breath Praise the Lord”
I have often found the idea of praise confusing because of what it says about God. Has He told us that we must praise Him? Why would an all-powerful being need us to praise Him? The idea that we are commanded by God to praise the Lord seems more like the actions of arrogant and…
-
A Schism of Loyalty: Aidan and Tristan Caplan on the Third Convention
When we study historical schisms in Christian churches, including Latter-day Saints, we usually encounter stories of bitter theological disputes, splinter groups following charismatic figures, or outright rejections of foundational doctrines. But what happens when nearly a third of a country’s members break away from Church headquarters—not because they reject the Restored Gospel, but because they…
-
Variety in our Meetings (Or What Did Church Lead You to Think About Yesterday), 8/16
One member of our ward was well-known for getting up every Fast Sunday and giving essentially the same testimony. He has a strong but simple testimony, one that many members might dismiss or ignore because it isn’t as “sophisticated” as what they would say. Illness now prevents him from attending our ward, but he remains…
-

CFM 8/24-8/30: Thoughts and Poetry for “I Will Declare What He Hath Done for My Soul”
The impact of Christ’s atonement is beyond calculation and likely beyond mortal comprehension. His sacrifice is pivotal in the life of those who will accept its life-changing help. Less-often discussed is our own role in the atonement — that is, without accepting it, and implementing it in our lives, Christ’s sacrifice is of little help.…
-

Responsibility in our Meetings (Or What Did Church Lead You to Think About Yesterday), 8/9
In the past few years, one of the most influential books I have read is Wayne C. Booth’s masterwork, The Company We Keep, his attempt to look at the role of ethics in literature. Booth is one of the most influential literary thinkers of the last half of the 20th century, and is responsible for…
-

CFM 8/17-8/23: Thoughts and Poetry for “The Lord Is My Shepherd”
The fact that the Psalms are poetry is more noticeable than other books of the Bible, where the poetry has been obscured by things like translation and changes in culture. In fact, scholars estimate that one-third to one-half of the Old Testament was originally written as poetry. As a result the Come Follow Me manual…
-

Extreme Pacifism and the Moriori: The Anti-Nephi Lehites of the South Pacific
The last full-blooded Moriori The Anti-Nephi Lehites are a compelling narrative. A formerly violent people who lay down their swords to the point of being willingly massacred, and then a deus ex machina sort of happens and they are saved by the conscience of their attackers. But what happens if the attackers don’t stop? What…
-

A “Great Work” in our Meetings (Or What Did Church Lead You to Think About Yesterday), 8/2
What is important in our meetings? Immediately, most church members will say the sacrament—which implies that the rest of sacrament meeting is just context. It is true that the sacrament represents the most (or perhaps only) important, or truly great, element of our theology and our practice. But we should probably think about what we…
-

CFM 8/10-8/16: Thoughts and Poetry for “Yet Will I Trust in Him””
Often today discussions of the book of Job focus on the dilemma of why bad things happen to good people—a philosophical question that is largely not answerable, at least not without significant difficulty. In contrast this lesson focuses on Job’s enduring trust in God in spite of the many sudden tragedies that have afflicted his…
-

Second Nature Reactions (Or What Did Church Lead You to Think About Yesterday), 7/26
If you don’t stop and think first, how do you react? Is your “second nature” reacting the way you want? Do you naturally react well? Or poorly? And what about your habitual reactions to what happens in Church? The term “second nature” is a little misleading, since there isn’t any first nature. “Second nature” comes…
-

CFM 8/3-8/9: Thoughts and Poetry for “Thou Art Come … for Such a Time as This”
The idea that someone like Esther had “come… for such a time as this,” implies that timing is important. At least in the case of a few crucial people, the right person arrives at the right time, when they can “seize the day” and make a difference. The idea is crucial to the hero’s journey,…
-

Judge Not in Church—or anywhere (Or What Did Church Lead You to Think About Yesterday), 7/12
”Judge Not” is a kind of cliché — and often a weapon we wield when someone says something we disagree with, or makes an incorrect judgment. Meanwhile, we hypocritically are judging them for what they said. We usually aren’t too concerned with the judgment itself. In addition, Joseph Smith’s translation of the Bible doesn’t help…
-

CFM 7/27-8/2: Thoughts and Poetry for “I Am Doing a Great Work”
How do we know that we are doing a “great work?” I think the problem often comes down to how we define the word “great.” Much of the time “great” is a comparative term — we think it’s about some things being great and other things being not great, and therefore not as worthy of…
-

A Preposterously Complimentary Review of the Book of Abraham
From guest blogger Kendall Buchanan One of the most popular bloggers on Substack, Scott Alexander, hosts an annual book review competition and posts submissions from finalists he selects. Alexander’s blog targets “rationalists”—a community predominantly made up of atheists, of which he is indisputably king. Last week’s anonymous finalist reviewed , of all things, the Book of Abraham.…
-

What You Should Talk About in the Foyer (Or What Did Church Lead You to Think About Yesterday), 7/12
Originally, the meaning of the French word ‘foyer’ was the center or focus of the home, its heart and hearth. While today we define it as the entry of the building, in practice the less-formal and more intimate conversations in the foyer of our buildings feel a bit more like what you would say at…
-

CFM 7/20-7/26: Thoughts and Poetry for “Our Eyes Are upon Thee”
The difficult reality of peace is that we often seek it only when we are under threat. This week’s Old Testament lesson emphasizes this idea, observing that at the time of this lesson, Israel was surrounded by three different enemies. But the idea of peace has a very different idea and context in the gospel.…
-

Church in Contrast: Participation and Meaning in Church (Or What Did Church Lead You to Think About) Yesterday, 7/5?
Have you ever compared two different Church meetings? Maybe Sunday School lessons in two different wards on the same day? I did yesterday, and the two Sunday School lessons were very different. But I learned something in each case. One lesson was much more to my preference—discussion based, less dogmatic, exploring. The other was more…
-

CFM 7/13-7/19: Thoughts and Poetry for “He Trusted in the Lord God of Israel”
We talk a lot about faith in our classes and sermons. It’s not hard to see why—faith is at once one of the crucial elements of our spiritual lives and one of the most difficult elements to practice. Add to that it’s tendency to conflict with “common sense” (which is in reality simply our understanding…
-

Simplifying in Church: Participation and Meaning in Church (Or What Did Church Lead You to Think About) Yesterday, 6/28?
Often today we are urged to simplify things. We boil down our tasks or our conceptions to the essential, to the “elevator pitch” —something that can be explained in a few words. There’s almost an industry teaching us how to make our businesses simpler, our tasks simpler, our lives simpler. But what do we loose…
