Latter-day Saint Apologetics Tier List

•

Tier lists are a fashionable/fun way to rank order things, ranging from F to S (super, above A). I already did one for arguments for the existence of God, so I thought I’d be a little more Latter-day Saint specific and do one for apologetics arguments for LDS truth claims. 

There are two kinds of apologetics arguments (roughly): “offensive” and “defensive.” The former being giving positive arguments for the faith, and the latter defending against attacks against the faith, so this list will focus on the former. Basically, from a logic-based perspective, what are some of the best arguments for accepting the Church’s truth claims? 

The obligatory throat-clearing: none of these are slam dunks. As originally stated by Carl Sagan and quoted by Richard Bushman, extraordinary claims require extraordinary evidence, so none of these are enough to compel belief in something as big as your religion. Nor are they meant to. Unlike other faith traditions, we don’t think you can reach the top of the mountain through intellect. Still, some arguments are better than others and, contrary to some sentiment in some corners of the internet, the top tier ones can’t be simply waved away either. Also, I cover a lot of this ground in my Latter-day Saint Scholars Testify testimony.   

F

  • Friend-of-a-friend, urban legend, faith-promoting rumors. Literally no value. Here I’ll put: 
    • Missionaries missing their Zone meeting at the top of the twin towers on September 11th (as an aside, my brother served in the New York, New York North mission on September 11th, and he thinks it’s cute that people think the mission was wealthy enough to have a Zone conference on the top of the World Trade Center). 
    • The Del Parsons fireside where that kid exclaimed that the red robe Jesus was the person who saved his parents.
    • That “12 signs of the true Church” story that circulated in missions in my day where a bunch of people all decided to find a Church that has the 12 characteristics outlined in the Bible, and they all ended up joining the Church. 
    • The temple elevator shafts in the Salt Lake Temple.
    • And on and on, I’m sure you can name some. 

D

  • Appeal to the Bible. There are a number of biblical scriptures we sort of see as potentially confirming the restorationist angle. Still, to paraphrase Joseph Smith, the Bible can be interpreted by so many people in so many different ways so as to destroy all confidence by appealing to the Bible. Still, not absolutely nothing, so the D.   

C-

  • Faith-promoting rumors that may be a little better sourced. Pacific Islander prophecies about the missionaries (and yes, I know they were also interpreted as supporting the Protestant missionaries), David O. McKay’s healing handkerchief (or maybe that isn’t quite so supported? Don’t know), the handcart stories in “17 Miracles.” The kind of miraculous historical stories that most faith traditions have, except instead of being healed by a holy relic they are healed by a priesthood blessing, etc. but the difference with the above being that they can actually be traced to a solid primary source and eyewitness testimony. Again, not nothing, and some of them more compelling than others historiography-wise but the fact that these sorts of stories are found in a lot of faith traditions argues against putting too much weight on them vis-a-vis the particulars of the Church of Jesus Christ of Latter-day Saints. 
  • The Church’s growth and survival. The Church has been on the tipping point of destruction many, many times, but it always seems to survive and even, at times, thrive. That being said, this can also be explained using a sort of Darwinian logic. Thousands of new religions have been born, and out of those thousands the vast majority die, and a small handful will survive a number of close calls and thrive. Early Christianity went through a similar process where it almost got snuffed out at birth, as did Islam, Judaism (I always thought it was ironic that the first historical reference to Israel was proclaiming its destruction [“Israel is laid waste—its seed is no more”], sort of a theme of people always thinking they’ve finally done in the Jews), and now the Church of Jesus Christ of Latter-day Saints. 

C+

  • On that note, I will actually put the prophecies about the Jewish gathering, and Orson Hyde’s dedication of the Holy Land for the return of the Jews, combined with Israel’s miraculous continued existence, as higher than the C-category. No, it doesn’t mean that I agree with every policy of the Netanyahu regime, but yes, the Jews returning to Judea is in fact prophesied fairly clearly in our Latter-day scriptures, and I think their presence in the Middle East today is a fulfillment of that prophecy, regardless of the political particulars.  
  • Book of Abraham facsimiles. Yes, I know the Robert Ritner fans are plucking out their hair at this one. In terms of translation he simply got much of the facsimiles wrong, but he also got some of the symbols right, and in the aggregate I think the accuracy was better than guessing, so, in full recognizance of the missed shots, once we step away from assuming infallibility on the part of the facsimiles, in the end he got more right than I think he would have by just making things up (Kolob, four corners of the earth, Sobke the crocodile God of Pharaoh, etc.), so in light of the pluses and minuses I’ll put this at a C+ level.  
  • Joseph Smith’s seer stones. Once again, this is usually seen as a criticism, but stay with me here. His treasure-hunting is seen as a sign of fraudulent behavior, but it’s clear from his keeping of stones and usage of them throughout his life that he himself believed in it. So a point for him having sincere supernatural beliefs even if he knew they probably wouldn’t go over well with traditional Christians wary of the occult, but sincerity only goes part way in defending LDS truth claims, hence the C+.

B-

At around the B- level we start to get into arguments I wouldn’t feel skittish bringing up with a hypothetical skeptical interlocutor. 

  • Hebraisms outside of chiasmus. Admittedly I’m not terribly familiar with these arguments, but I remember reading them and thinking they were interesting, but could also be chalked up to the happenstance of the KJV style that BoM imitated lining up with Hebrew. Plus the final Nephite language was probably far removed from paleo-Hebrew or whatever. So it’s interesting and there might be something there, I guess.
  • Deification/Divine council/Concentric circles of holiness. Joseph Smith had a knack for tapping into deep religious themes that were long since lost to the kind of low-Church Protestant upbringing that he was raised in, but are found in earlier texts and iterations of the faith, as well as across faiths worldwide, such as deification, the divine council, and the sort of concentric circles of holiness that undergird temple worship. Again, maybe he was simply bold enough to tap into Jungian archetypes regardless of how heretical they were to Nicene Christianity, but still, it is intriguing that in the restored Church you do get practices and beliefs that were, well, restored. 
  • Family testimony. As I mentioned in my Joseph Smith/L. Ron Hubbard post, it is a significant point in Smith’s favor that the people that knew him best, his family, basically saw him as sincere and loving, and accepted his calling as a prophet, even if polygamy caused legitimate stresses. Doesn’t prove anything per se, but it would make any chicanery on his part much deeper and more subtle than your run-of-the-mill conman psychopath that leaves a trail of destruction in his wake.   
  • Latter-day Saint cosmology. While there are heretical exceptions that met their end at the stake, the idea that there are numberless stars with planetary systems and worlds was bizarre in Joseph Smith’s day, and I think we sometimes don’t appreciate just how revolutionary and weird that belief was that later turned out to be correct. 

B

  • Chiasmus. TBH, I’m kind of agnostic on this one. It seems like some of this could just be happenstance, but then there are the statistical studies that purport to show that they aren’t happenstance, but I haven’t done a deep enough dive on them to know if there’s any merit there. Alma 36 seems kind of compelling. I’d have to spend more time on this to really be able to gauge its apologetic value. I could be convinced either way. 
  • Wordprint studies. Ditto. It’s neat that we have these studies and that they show different authors for the Book of Mormon, but again I’d have to dive deeper than I have into this literature to really be able to adjudicate it. 

B+

  • Word of Wisdom. It’s not flawless (the reason for hot drinks is still not clear health-wise), and my understanding is there was some speculation about alcohol/tobacco being unhealthy even then, but in general the LDS health code being more or less right is a point for the Church. 
  • Nahom, Bountiful, and Arabian itinerary. Getting geographic details right is impressive. Of course, could still be a coincidence but still a solid hit. 
  • Book of Mormon incorporating other ancient texts. A number of places in the Book of Mormon incorporate other ancient texts that strongly argue against Joseph Smith just making it all up on the fly, whether “all the ships of the Sea” in the Isaiah passages or Josephus/Book of Mormon both contradicting the Torah in saying that Moses was translated. At least clearly argues for something along the lines of Joseph Smith “studying it out in his mind” (and yes, I know a standard apologetic line is that there is no evidence that Joseph Smith ever consulted other books during the translation process, but I have a hard time seeing how both the Textus Receptus errors made it into the BoM along with the older, pre-KJV readings). 

A

  • Book of Mormon narrative complexity. As somebody who got a B in Book of Mormon at BYU, I can attest to its narrative complexity. It’s the kind of thing that the Mark Twains of this world can just blow past when they’re skimming the Book of Mormon just to say that they “read” it, but when your grade is on the line you all of the sudden realize how mind-numbingly complex all the parallel storylines and casts of characters can be. Hard to see this as being written extemporaneously; it would have required some savant-like ability to keep names, locations, and storylines straight. 
  • Shared visions. While we make a big deal about the Book of Mormon Witnesses never renouncing their testimonies, we sometimes forget that Oliver Cowdery and Sidney Rigdon both had mutual revelatory experiences with Joseph Smith, Oliver Cowdery in D&C 110 and Sidney Rigdon in D&C 76. If he was a conscious fraudster it’s highly doubtful he would have exposed himself to that level of risk by involving others. Oliver Cowdery could have easily come out and simply said “actually, we didn’t see Jesus in the Kirtland temple,” and likewise Rigdon could have disclaimed experiencing the revelation about heaven. The fact that they were both involved strongly suggests something happened or at least that there was some sort of collective hallucination, but not so much intentional deceit. 

A+

  • Civil War prophecy. Yes, South Carolina was in a tariff crisis when the revelation was first received, but even putting aside the fact that dispute over federalist principles does not necessarily equal a full blown north versus south, intra-country violent war, the fact is that Smith doubled down on the prophecy with more detail in D&C 130 in 1843, long after the tariff crisis was resolved but meaningfully before the Civil War. So yes, this is a very specific “hit.”
  • Book of Mormon witnesses. I don’t know if I have much more to add to my take on the witnesses than I’ve already discussed here and here. Again, does it force you into a corner? No, but it’s not as easily hand-waved away as some think.

S

  • Kinderhook plates. Wait, what? How is this S-tier for the Church? Stay with me here. Don Bradley’s presentation at FAIR on this pretty clearly demonstrated that Joseph Smith used the Book of Abraham as a crib sheet to try to translate the characters the forgers transcribed on the Kinderhook plates…which means that he sincerely believed in his translations. He literally tried to use them to help with other translations, and was unclear enough about his modus operandi that it wasn’t for another century and a half before scholars realized fully what he was doing. This puts an arrow in the heart of the idea that he didn’t believe in what he was doing, and it’s one reason for why, even if I were to take a naturalist view of the restoration, I would think that Joseph Smith eventually, at least by the 1840s, believed in his own prophetic ability.




Comments

8 responses to “Latter-day Saint Apologetics Tier List”

  1. I’m also ambivalent about chiasmus. I think it’s a good example of the Book of Mormon’s complexity and how aspects of the text can escape notice for 150 years before anyone notices them, but it gets more attention than it deserves. B tier, but overall complexity is an A tier for me. The Book of Mormon has a depth that is hard to explain.

    I’d put the physicality of the golden plates in the B+/A range. They sound so improbable, but in the contemporary historical documents, their physical reality is hard to wave away. Joseph Smith doesn’t act like someone trying to keep a fiction going, but like someone trying to keep possession of a very real stack of metallic plates.

    I agree that the Kinderhook Plates belong somewhere near the top. They get treated as a scandal, but they actually point in the opposite direction.

    As you say, none of this is conclusive, but a lot of it is far weirder than dismissive accounts of early church history depict it.

  2. I’m glad I’m not the only one who thinks the Kinderhook plates are strong evidence for Joseph’s prophethood. If you know metal plates are a fabrication of your imagination, what better way to prove you’re a prophet than “discerning” a plot to entrap you? But if you’ve dealt with metal plates before and expect to find more, wouldn’t you be excited to find them?

  3. For the Chiasmus’ and other Hebrew parallel poetry in the Book of Mormon, one of the podcasts I listed to went over where they are found in the Book of Mormon. The common pattern is that they a found where a righteous individual is writing. The letters from the Lamanites don’t have them, the off-the-cuff discussions don’t have them. Going over that just blew my mind.

  4. Under Book of Mormon complexity, one thing I find compelling is that the drivers of important plot points are sometimes never explained. Fiction writers don’t do that.

    Zeniff’s effort to recolonize the Land of Nephi was in defiance of the prophetic command given to King Mosiah(1) for the Nephites to leave that land. Nothing goes right for long, even for Alma’s repentant people, until they obey that commandment and return to Zarahemla. This would have been a classic place for some “And thus we see…” commentary from Mormon, but he never says it. Maybe he didn’t want to bring out that the Nephite Church was started among an apostate people. You have to look at the story as a whole and connect it back to previous history to see it.

    King Mosiah(2) strongly opposes sending anyone to the Land of Nephi to check on the people who went there. Apparently he fears that this will stir up the desire to return (even Captain Moroni is briefly tempted by it). The time when the people demand that he send an expedition is described as the end of a period of peace. When they finally force his hand, he very cleverly puts a descendent of Zarahemla in charge, not a Nephite, even though this is Nephite business. Ammon(1) has no emotional ties to the Land of Nephi and is not at all tempted to stay there. It wouldn’t surprise me if the whole expedition was made up of Mulekites.

    Mormon dutifully records that Ammon was chosen, but doesn’t say anything about the significance of the choice. Maybe he didn’t recognize it. For a fiction writer, this would have been one of the highlights of Mosiah’s story: how he outmaneuvered his opponents and helped bring all the Nephites home to Zarahemla where they belonged.

  5. RLD: I think there may be even more political intrigue beneath Mormon’s narration than you’ve suggested, particularly involving the relationship between the Nephites and Mulekites.

    When Mosiah(1) arrived in Zarahemla, the Mulekites apparently constituted the majority population, yet the Nephites assumed control of both the monarchy and religious institutions. Mosiah 25:13 is especially revealing: the people of Zarahemla were numbered among the Nephites because “the kingdom had been conferred upon none but those who were descendants of Nephi.” This raises questions about how the descendants of Zarahemla, including those who may have traced their ancestry to the royal house of Judah through Mulek, regarded their political subordination.

    Ammon’s identification as a descendant of Zarahemla in Mosiah 7:3 might therefore be more significant than it initially appears. Was he a member of a surviving Mulekite aristocracy? If so, sending him to recover a lost Nephite colony could have served several political purposes simultaneously: accommodating Mulekite elites by entrusting one of their own with a prestigious mission, distancing a potential rival from Zarahemla, and perhaps avoiding the appearance that Mosiah was personally interested in restoring a competing Nephite monarchy.

    I also find Ammon’s reaction to his imprisonment intriguing. In Mosiah 7:13, he tells Limhi that had he known who Ammon was, he would never have placed him in bonds. Could this reflect a consciousness of elevated political or genealogical status? There is also a certain irony in a descendant of Zarahemla being dispatched to the ancestral homeland of the Nephites, only to encounter another monarchy whose legitimacy rested partly on popular selection (Mosiah 7:9).

    This raises a larger question about the subsequent abolition of monarchy under Mosiah(2). If Mulekite elites retained memories of their own royal ancestry, did the establishment of the reign of judges eliminate their remaining hopes of recovering kingship? Might some of the later movements to restore monarchy, particularly the king-men described in Alma 51, have drawn upon unresolved tensions between the descendants of Nephi and Zarahemla? The text never explicitly establishes such a connection, but its references to high birth, hereditary privilege, and competing claims to political authority make the possibility worth considering.

    Even the later identification of Coriantumr as a descendant of Zarahemla (Helaman 1:15) suggests that Mulekite ancestry remained sufficiently meaningful to warrant preservation in the narrative.

    None of this establishes that Ammon was a political rival or that the king-men represented a Mulekite faction. But it does raise the possibility that Mormon’s seemingly incidental genealogical details preserve traces of a much longer struggle over political legitimacy within a society whose majority population had been incorporated into a ruling Nephite identity. Your interpretation of Mosiah’s maneuvering may be one glimpse of that larger, largely untold history.

  6. Along with Sterling’s comment, I might add that the Jaredites are similarly enigmatic. On a surface reading, they would appear to have nearly no connection to the rest of the Book of Mormon narrative. But then you have these vague hints all over the place about records and engraved stones and piles of bones and even a contemporary survivor, and it raises unanswerable questions about how much more might be going on with them.

  7. Not a Cougar

    Sterling, I’ll see your “Nephite foreign dynasty” theory and raise you a “The book of Alma is largely a sanitized retelling of a Mulekite popular religious and political movement in opposition to the unpopular Nephite foreign dynasty.”

  8. TexasAbuelo

    As I’ve aged I’ve concluded that the BofM multiple, remarkably concise, mini-treatises on the extraordinarily demanding principle of “equality” – in the spheres of religious belief, the political arena, religious organizations, and interpersonal relationships – is without equal. People get so easily hung up on the “white/black” skin color deal that they miss the essence of the teachings of the Book . We once asked our parents about the white/black skin color changing deal – their answer “use the brains the good Lord gave ya, you already know people don’t go around changing colors – so we’re not catching something- don’t worry about it… the point is what? steer clear of people who ignore their covenants – and you can see ‘em a mile away because the “light’s “ gone out of their countenance”… That served me well the last 70 years – light on, or light off!! No more complicated than that . When I met AfroLatino members on my mission in South America pre-‘78 .. their countenances burned bright as could be with the light of the Spirit, those erroneously denied the priesthood. We warmed our hearts by the light of their extraordinary faith burning so bright we could pick them out of a crowd though we’d never met them…
    Anyway ruminations of a very old Mormon

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

This site uses Akismet to reduce spam. Learn how your comment data is processed.