A Standard Polygamy Narrative?

•

What I mean by the title of this post is what I see as the most common church narrative for polygamy that I’ve heard over the years. Polygamy is something church leaders and members generally want to downplay, and yet it takes up a good chunk of our history and is hard to make go away.

So with the caveat that lots of people have their own take on this, I’d say our standard church narrative is something like this: “God commanded Joseph Smith and the early Mormons to do it. It’s connected to Old Testament practice. It was only meant to be practiced for a short time, and monogamy is the norm. Let’s move on!”

My point of this post is that I see this standard narrative as leaving quite a few historical and theological questions.

First, such statements tend not to address the fact that men can be sealed to other wives if previous wives die, but women can’t do that if a husband dies. That practice, of course, tends to make polygamy an ongoing issue for members.

Second, there’s the tricky issue of what we put in our scriptures of Wilford Woodruff’s explanation for ending polygamy:

The Lord has told me to ask the Latter-day Saints a question … Which is the wisest course for the Latter-day Saints to pursue—to continue to attempt to practice plural marriage, with the laws of the nation against it and the opposition of sixty millions of people, and at the cost of the confiscation and loss of all the Temples, and the stopping of all the ordinances therein, both for the living and the dead, and the imprisonment of the First Presidency and Twelve and the heads of families in the Church, and the confiscation of personal property of the people (all of which of themselves would stop the practice); or, after doing and suffering what we have through our adherence to this principle to cease the practice and submit to the law.

The strong implication of Woodruff’s explanation was that the Lord said we needed to stop because the United States government was forcing us to stop.

So did we stop because God only intended the church to practice polygamy for a relatively short time because monogamy is the norm, or did we stop because the United States government made us?

This reminds me of an exchange on my mission many years ago when polygamy came up in a chat we were having with a non-member. “You’d still be practicing it if the government hadn’t made you stop,” he asserted. My companion said emphatically, “I know we would not,” and I remember saying less emphatically “I don’t know.”

Then there are a whole host of other issues that I think DaveW addressed well on my first post on this topic:

For me, concerns about polygamy are really a manifestation of a deeper issue: the church is unable or unwilling to clarify past practices and statements. I assume many here are familiar with statements about polygamy from Brigham Young (“the only men who become gods . . . are those who enter into polygamy”) or John Taylor’s 1886 revelation (“I have not revoked this law, nor will I, for it is everlasting”) which the church denied the existence for 100 years.

There are two extreme paths here. One is to throw previous presidents of the church under the bus and repudiate past teachings as just plain wrong. The other is to embrace polygamy as an eternal principle, though perhaps one we have to forgo for the time being for practical reasons. The Church has instead opted for a middle path that, despite decades of trying, they don’t seem to be able to un-muddy. Polygamy was right then, but wrong now, and it wasn’t very common, or it was just to take care of widows, or to raise up a righteous seed, or for other reasons that history and data don’t support, and all those statements are best left alone, or were a product of their time. It’s a perpetual game of tap dancing around the issue trying to find any rational that will make the questioner stop asking the question right now.

A good summary, and like I said in my first post, I see a difference between polygamy issues and the priesthood ban for two reasons. 1) Racism was a common attitude in the US and we can thus at least partially blame the priesthood ban on church leaders improperly taking on problematic attitudes of the larger society. Polygamy was very much at odds with the norms of the society to the point that it caused all the problems that Woodruff noted. 2) With Young implementing the ban, we often work to distance Joseph Smith from it. With polygamy, Smith practiced it, and while a fallible leader may have a bank fail, if he implements a religious policy we consider really really bad (I know opinions differ) that had nothing to do with larger societal norms, at what point does that start to call the legitimacy of the religion he implemented into question?

So I see that as the bind we’re in. And I’ll close with the proposal from Kendall in my first post. Would allowing women to be sealed to other husbands if previous ones die help alleviate many of our ongoing polygamy problems?


Comments

24 responses to “A Standard Polygamy Narrative?”

  1. “Would allowing women to be sealed to other husbands if previous ones die help alleviate many of our ongoing polygamy problems?”

    I think the fundamental objection many members have to polygamy is that they believe polygamous marriages are inherently less happy than monogamous marriages. That’s especially true for women: when they say “I don’t want to share my husband” that’s because they believe they’ll be more happy with a husband that’s 100% committed to them. That belief is based on what we’re taught about marriage in the Church, what we observe in the world around us, and on the historical record of polygamy.

    I don’t think very many of those women will be mollified by being told “You can have multiple husbands too!” Maybe if the prime concern were having someone to be with when their husband is with another wife. It has the potential to shift some men’s attitudes, as they consider the prospect of their wife (or wives) not being 100% committed to them.

    Maybe it’s all different with celestial people in a celestial world. Maybe. Can God make two people his top priority? Does the question imply a scarcity that does not exist in the Celestial Kingdom?

    It does have the advantage of allowing us preserve all the (happy) marriages we form in this life. That’s a good thing, but I’m not sure it’s the most important thing. I’m in favor of it as a policy change, but mostly following the principle of “seal them all, let God sort it out.”

  2. Not a Cougar

    Stephen, to your question, no, I don’t think that allowing a living woman to be sealed to multiple men (i.e., a dead husband and a living husband) really solves anything from an LDS theological standpoint given that, once she dies, she’ll be sealed to every man to whom she was married anyway (see General Handbook para. 38.4.1.8), but it might make living men and women feel like they are on more equal footing which would be a good thing.

    Also, I’m on board with Dave W’s statement. The Church really isn’t willing to throw previous presidents of the Church under the bus completely and repudiate its polygamy teaching nor will it come out and say that polygamy is an eternal principle (President Oaks’ and President Nelson’s multiple sealings not withstanding) leaving it with this “muddy middle way.” And yet, this middle way seems to have worked tolerably well. People might complain about polygamy, and it might even be one of many reasons a person might leave the Church, but, at least in my experience, polygamy has rarely been the sole reason for someone’s departure. Do we reach a point in the Church where “something’s gotta give?” Maybe, but the end of polygamy itself provides a useful lesson about how the Church operates. Big muscle movements in the Church rarely happen unless outside (and sometimes inside) pressure reach a point that Church leaders feel they have no choice but to make the change (and even that requires a lot of politicking and even funerals amongst the First Presidency and Quorum of the Twelve).

  3. Kendall Buchanan

    Stephen,

    Regarding the standard narrative: Many conversations I’ve had with other church members about polygamy—always in private, and usually men—have led me to think that most Saints who reflect on the subject from a believing, supplicating position think that polygamy is the order of heaven, not the norm. It’s hard for mere mortals to accept. God commands it infrequently because it’s not natural to the fallen man, and we have to be cagey about it because it’s casting pearls before swine.

    (Which, to be fair, is a point about life itself: If we knew all that God knew, would we still do it?)

  4. Stephen Fleming

    RLD, I do think women (and other members) are aware of the unfairness of men being able to be “resealed” if their wife dies, but women are not, and thus I’m in favor of the change also.

    Cougar, thanks for the reference. It says, “If a husband and wife have been sealed and the husband dies, the woman may not be sealed to another man unless she receives a cancellation of the first sealing.” So I don’t see where it says, “once she dies, she’ll be sealed to every man to whom she was married anyway.”

    In terms of “something’s gotta give,” I do think we have a polygamy problem and I do think that issues with it do add to concerns and people leaving. Concerned Mormons do have other concerns, but I’d say that polygamy is up there. I’m not implying that women being allowed to have multiple sealings will “fix” everything, but my sense is that it would be an improvement.

    It does come across as awkward to read just a couple of paragraphs below the one you cited, “Men. If a husband and wife have been sealed and the wife dies, the man may be sealed to another woman if she is not already sealed to another man.” Yeah, not fair.

    Kendall, yes, good point. I’d say that the summary I gave is more along the lines of a more “official” position from church leaders. The kind of position we want to state when we’re aware that outsiders are listening.

    But yes, my sense is that to lots of members there is something more official about polygamy than we state in those more official statements. And no doubt a lot of women find that concerning.

  5. Kendall, funny but the private conversation that I have had, mostly with women, the feeling is very strongly that monogamy is the order of heaven and polygamy was a mistake almost exactly like the ban on blacks having the priesthood was a mistake. And while one was kind of because that was the common feeling among the population, the other is like it in that most men lust after more than just their first wife. So, one was common among the general population and the other was just common among the male population.

  6. stephen, re “cougar….i dont see….”: it literally does

    Sealing of Deceased Persons
    Deceased Women. A deceased woman may be sealed to all men to whom she was legally married during her life. The following table shows when these sealings may take place.

  7. Stephen Fleming

    Anna, it’s not too shocking that men and woman talk about this differently.

    dlc, thanks for the clarification. I was counting 8 paragraphs rather than going to .8. That is certainly an interesting chart which I think brings up some more questions. I’m curious how long that’s been in place (sorry if that is well known!).

  8. On the subject of John Taylor and Brigham Young, I think Jonathan Stapley has found some good evidence to show that at least Young went back and forth on whether polygamy was really necessary for exaltation or not in Holiness to the Lord. For example:

    February 12, 1870, Salt Lake City, Utah

    President Young said there would be men saved in the Celestial Kingdom of God with one wife, with many wives, and with no wife at all.

    June 18, 1870, Paris, Idaho

    President David P. Kimball asked a question with regard to the glory to be obtained by those having one or more wives
    President [Brigham] Young explained it by a parable of measures of various capacities and said that all were not equal in their capacities for glory but all would receive Celestial glory if they held out faithful to the end whether they had but one wife or many.

    June 10, 1871, Paris, Idaho

    President [Charles] Rich concluded by saying a man who had one wife sealed to him by the Priesthood was in the same covenant and entitled to the same promises and the same conditions as he who had more. Both are on a level concerning promises and satisfaction. All endowments and sealings are on condition that those who receive them continue in the Covenant. Any person depending on promises alone for his salvation will be greatly mistaken.

    July 15, 1871, Paris, Idaho

    President [Brigham] Young answered … a man can obtain as full a salvation with one wife as with more but it will not be so great. His work will be slow, but it would be better for us to enquire about the duties of today than about things we do not understand.

    These are, admittedly, not as clear or common as the public statements that it was required for exaltation, but they do show a lack of consistent conviction about the point.

  9. I’m feeling very famous today. I’ll try not to let it go to my head.

    I think what makes polygamy such an important topic for so many is how it touches our daily lives. I spend more time with my wife than any other person. My marriage is the single largest influence on my day-to-day life. The idea of fundamentally changing that would up-end my life more than just about anything else I can think of. Messing with our personal lives on that level, whether in this life or the next, is a *big thing*. Polygamy is a deeply personal practice that is hard to keep emotional distance from.

    Polygamy also has a lot of details available to us. Many of us have ancestors who were in plural marriages. We’ve read their journals. We’ve heard stories, both good and bad. We know the specifics. And then we have standard narratives that are so very vague. If polygamy was to be practiced “for a short time”, why 60(ish) years? (People were living in plural marriages well into the 1900s.) Why not one guy with two wives, check the box and move on? Why did some church leaders have dozens of wives? With huge age gaps? (The questions could go on and on and on . . . .)

  10. Not a Cougar

    Stephen, a quick Google search suggests that the policy of sealing a deceased woman to all of the men to whom she was married in life indicates the First Presidency issued a policy letter in December 1988 to that effect and that the Handbook was updated in 1989 to implement it and that there were further updates in 1991. I’ll caveat all of this by saying I haven’t been able to pull up the source documents themselves so I can’t verify those statements. If anyone else can get to them to verify or debunk the above, I’d be grateful.

  11. I agree with Nibley–that marriage is different in the afterlife than it is in mortality.

    It is certainly similar typologically–but different in ways that only exalted beings can experience.

  12. Unconvinced

    The only way your proposed shared marriage sometimes called polyamory makes polygamy more palatable is that it is not as sexist and unfair to women. It doesn’t resolve anything because the doctrine and history still stand the same, Unrehabilitated.

    Why try? It was a bad doctrine that hurt people and the church and drags down the current church. Let it go. Don’t try to justify it or reform it. Since it was wrong from the start.

  13. Stephen Fleming

    Thanks for those quotes, Chad. The Utah period isn’t my specialty, but I remember Tom Alexander saying in my Utah history class many years ago that it was standard for Utah church leaders to interpret DC 131:1-4 as being about polygamy. That is, there are different degrees in the Celestial Kingdom and polygamy was required for the top degree. These quotes seem to suggest a similar point of view. Non-polygamists can get into the Celestial Kingdom but there seems to be advantages to polygamists.

    Cougar, thanks for looking. I get the need to be able to seal female ancestors to multiple spouses since death of spouses has been common throughout history. I do wonder how long the caveat about Mormon women who’d been sealed in life being able to have living relatives seal them to other spouses after they die has been in place.

    Jack, I’m guessing you and Nibley are correct.

    Unconvinced, the topic of this post was about what I see as the difficulties polygamy creates for the church. I asked at the end if allowing women to be sealed other husbands if the first dies would help with the problem at all. You claim that shared marriage “is not as sexist and unfair to women,” so I guess you do see such an allowance as an improvement.

  14. Stephen Fleming

    And thanks for your contributions, DaveW. This certainly is a tricky subject, and I agree that those elements of what is often a standard narrative leave a lot of questions.

  15. I’m guessing that Jack and Nibley are correct as far as they go. It’s just that they don’t go far enough. I don’t think any of us really know about the circumstances of our afterlife. I don’t think we can know–it’s beyond our limited mortal ability to comprehend. We are all just doing the best we can, based on what we individually like most about our lives here.

    As to the topic in general, it’s very telling that the conversation is all mostly men talking to men. When a woman does weigh in, her input is easily and lightly dismissed.

  16. Stephen Fleming

    My apologies for being dismissive of women, PWS. That wasn’t my intention. The blog does seem to be disproportionately male, and we would certainly like to be engaging and inviting to more women.

  17. “So did we stop because God only intended the church to practice polygamy for a relatively short time because monogamy is the norm, or did we stop because the United States government made us?”
    Um, both? From what I understand, God rarely if ever just “zaps” a prophet with a revelation. Revelations invariably come in response to questions. When the time came for us to stop practicing polygamy, He allowed the U. S. government to put enough pressure on the church for Pres. Woodruff to start asking the questions that opened the way for the revelation to occur.
    I’ll also tell a story that I think is relevant for people who worry about living women only being sealed to a single husband.
    When he was first called to the 12, one of Elder Bednar’s sons lived in our ward, and until that son completed his degree and moved away Elder Bednar visited two or three times a year to see his grandchildren. He would usually agree to hold a fireside that took the form of “Ask Me Anything” (although he always started with some instructions on what sorts of questions were appropriate.) One brothers question was: his parents were sealed in the temple, and he and his siblings were born in the covenant, but then the parents were divorced and had their sealing annulled. He wondered how that annulment affected his sealing to his parents.
    Elder Bednar answered that he was still entitled to all the blessings pertaining to being born in the covenant, and that his parents subsequent choices couldn’t change that. Then he added something to the effect that we often imagine the celestial kingdom as being like our earth life, where we live in family units, but that probably wasn’t exactly correct.
    I don’t know what the celestial kingdom will be like, but I know it will be good and glorious. I don’t think there’s anything wrong with speculating about it, but we shouldn’t take our speculations and imaginations so seriously that they lead us to abandon our covenants and disqualify ourselves from receiving celestial blessings. Some may consider this “dismissive”, but I’d prefer to say that I’m comfortable “putting the issue on the shelf.”

  18. Truth is, no one knows what relationships look like in the eternities. My guess is the sealing power was to seal up the family of God. To be fair, females should be allowed to be sealed to multiple men while alive. Think about the unfortunate young mom whose husband dies young. No men desiring a sealed marriage will be interested. Seal kids to multiple parents as well. It doesn’t matter.

    For those proponents of polygamy, guess what, you won’t have a partner in the next life. The gals will all be given to the boys in the red chairs. So I’ll most likely lose my wife of 45 years. We’ll be like the lost boys of Hilldale. There’s a reason the birthrate of males to females is roughly equal. There’s a ying and yang balance in the universe. And no, females will not out number males in the Celestial Kingdom.

    I’m hoping the afterlife is led by a matriarchy. It will be really entertaining to watch some good old boys. More females will continue to leave if the boys don’t address this issue of fairness.

  19. Stephen Fleming

    Curtis, it does seem that a number of commenters do see the afterlife as a little different, but it still seems as though allowing women to be sealed to other spouses if the first dies is more fair.

    Neal, yes, I’m thinking about posting about the situation you describe as I have been in a ward with a woman that happened to. And, I’m not sure how the afterlife will work, but your scenario sounds interesting.

  20. If fairness as currently practiced in the church is any indication of what will happen in eternity, plan kn their not being much of it.

  21. Polygamy seems like a mistake.

    Why make it so complicated? Polygamy was wrong and continues to be wrong and trying to force the concept into a shared marriage doesn’t reform the past or make it right. It doesn’t really matter if Joseph Smith said it was gods will. You can look the mess it made and judge for yourself. It was terrible for Emma and the near 40 other wives. It was terrible for my ancestors that practiced it. It doesn’t need to be reformed, it should be left in the past.

  22. Stephen Fleming

    Anon, that’s a good point.

    Unconvinced/Mistake, you’re not really engaging with the OP. Your ancestors practiced polygyny not shared marriage.

  23. Unconvinced/Mistake

    Share marriage isn’t polygamy, nor is it preferable to plain old marriage to me. I can’t see how it resolves the “common narrative” about polygamy. I would bet the most common belief about polygamy is that it was a mistake, not that it is some kind of eternal principle that could be reformed by widening the definition of marriage for a communal shared marriage you have advocated for. My ancestors didn’t practice shared marriage, but I don’t see how shared marriage is any better besides maybe that women could have multiple male sexual partners and that would be more equal? Sounds messy and more like polyamory.

  24. Stephen Fleming

    Yes, indeed messy. Probably one of the reason why Smith’s close followers pushed for a different system, polygyny, around 1843 (thus DC 132 that year). But the point of this post is to note the many tricky issues around this topic including the theological issues that come up with claiming that Smith made that big of a mistake. It seems like we have to deal with that issue, and you don’t address it.

    And I’m NOT saying we should be practicing shared marriage! Plato says that the practices in his REPUBLIC of goods and wives in common may only be possible in heaven. Just like Smith scaled back shared goods to tithing because we were unable to accomplish goods in common, it’s pretty clear that marriages in common would be MUCH harder.

    But we have all these issues in our history including a bunch of statements from early leaders, which brings up a lot to talk about and to try to understand.

    So, yes, I do see that fact that shared marriage is more fair as being important when it comes to attempting to understand all this. I argue in my dissertation and forthcoming book that Smith’s male inner circle didn’t like sharing wives so they put on pressure to switch to polygyny (long story) which was solidified with DC 132. In 1843, Smith switched to marrying mostly single mostly single “women,” and I put that in quotes since a lot were teenagers. The ages of the wives dropped because of the switch away from shared marriage and I think we can rightly view wives being a lot younger as problematic.

    But again, I’m not saying we should be practicing shared marriage.

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

This site uses Akismet to reduce spam. Learn how your comment data is processed.