
Given developments in population genetics It is common now to posit that Lehi et al., intermarried with pre-existing indigenous populations in the Americas. The main impetus for this was the early population demography that showed that Native American Y-chromosomes (for the male lines) and mitochondrial DNA (for the female lines) came out of East, and not Southwest, Asia.
This is all old hat and I don’t have much to say to the standard take on this, except I wanted to add another reason that I haven’t see as discussed for why our only two options are basically indigenous intermarriage or the BoM is fiction: population genetic viability.
There have been some recent interesting takes on the minimum number of people that you can have in order to avoid so much inbreeding that your population is doomed from the start. For example, one paper calculated the minimum number of people needed to assure that a crewed space mission to Proxima Centauri would need to not die off if they were assigned mates according to genetic differences (98). If we accept lower probabilities. “A initial amount of 25 breeding pairs of settlers drives the mission towards extinction in 50 +/- 15% of cases if we completely forbid inbreeding.”
Less interestingly, research done by scientists trying to resurrect endangered species suggests that
Evidence accumulated since 1980 shows that genetically effective population size (Ne) = 50 is inadequate for preventing inbreeding depression over five generations in the wild, with Ne > 100 being required to limit loss in total fitness to <10%. Further, even Ne = 500 is too low for retaining evolutionary potential for fitness in perpetuity.
So you can see where I’m going with this. Feel free to correct me, but according to my count the founding Lehite colony had: Lehi, Sariah, Zoram, Ishmael, Ishmael’s wife, and possibly the wives of Ishmael’s two sons, so seven genetically distinct founding individuals. (There’s some Church leader speculation that Ishmael’s two sons married Lehi’s daughters, so that would make five individuals, but let’s assume otherwise). These numbers are clearly too low to form a viable population. Furthermore, they are low enough that the mating with outsiders would have had to have happened fairly soon.* (The one other historically documented population I can think of that is kind of like Lehi’s is the relatively isolated Pitcairn Island community that descended from 27 UK mutineers and Polynesians in 1790 that grew to about 200 people after 70 years, and 5,742 by the late 20th century).
As I said, I don’t have much to say that hasn’t already been said on the pre-existing people that Lehi’s family mixed with and all the hints we find in the early Book of Mormon to that effect, except that the idea that the Lehi colony independently founded a self-perpetuating civilization kind of smells like the standard “these two people escaped and started their own civilization” trope that we see all throughout the ancient world, whether the survivors of Troy founding Rome, the house of Abraham, Noah, Deucalion and Pyrrha, etc. Of course, if you’re looking for naturalistic explanations Joseph Smith could have derived the theme from the Bible, but it is likely that by the time of the Mormon edits a thousand years after Lehi the foundation story of their civilization had morphed into the kind of simple founder event we see across world religions but which are genetically implausible if not impossible,** even if there are hints of the original, more complicated story still in the Book of Mormon text.
________________________________________________________
*We already know this from the paper, but to give it some color I had GPT run the interbreeding equations to see how long an N=7 colony could last with random mating, and it estimated about four generations/100 years before it fell below replacement level (yes yes, caveat emptor and all that with the AI, but I’m using the AI model that has helped solve open Erdos mathematics problems that remained unsolved for a century, so unless you’re using GPT 6.1 Sol or above I don’t want to hear about AI slop. It might have very rare inaccuracies, but at this level I trust it more than I would if I or another genetics amateur spent an hour or two getting my head around the equations and doing it myself). Anyway, according to that estimate the colony with that amount of genetic variation would last about a century, or four generations, before their fertility dropped below-replacement.
** Of course God can twiddle the genetics around to make the population viable, but then we’re entering into God burying dinosaur bones territory that I’m a priori skeptical about.

Leave a Reply